One of the most surprising things about The Assassination of Gianni Versace: American Crime Story is how much time the show is spending not just with Andrew Cunanan, but with his less famous victims. Prior to murdering Versace, Cunanan had already killed four men in a killing spree spanning several states, and this week's episode (in-keeping with the show's reverse Cunanan chronology) centers on his third victim, Lee Miglin, and briefly on his fourth, William Reese.
"A Random Killing" commits so thoroughly to fleshing out the character of Miglin (Mike Farrell)—a Chicago real estate tycoon whose ties to Cunanan remain ambiguous to this day—that Gianni Versace and his family don't appear in the episode at all. Let's get into five talking points from tonight's hour.
1) Cunanan's breath-play antics last week were a callback to his third murder.
Remember the nameless elderly man Cunanan seduced and then very nearly smothered with masking tape in last week's episode? Of course you do. That startling sequence makes a lot more sense in light of this episode, which takes place several weeks prior and sees Cunanan murdering Miglin in a very similar fashion. In real life, it was never proven whether Miglin and Cunanan knew each other prior to the murder (the FBI considers it likely they did, which the Miglin family staunchly denies), but in the show, Miglin's depicted as a deeply closeted regular client of Cunanan's—and a pretty heartbreaking character in his own right.
2) Cunanan's self-loathing emerges in his cruelty to Miglin.
Though the murder itself was brutal—a police officer notes that every one of Miglin's ribs was broken—it's the viciousness of Cunanan's words that really stand out in this episode. Despite knowing theirs is purely a business relationship, Miglin seems quietly besotted with Cunanan, who in turns seems repulsed. Miglin is touchingly eager to tell Cunanan about his plans to build a 125-story tower (the tallest in the world) in Chicago and name it The Sky Needle. "I've wanted to share this with you for a long time," he tells Cunanan, who all but sneers in his face, mocking both Miglin's ambitions and his clear emotional investment in their relationship.
Later, when Cunanan brutally kills Miglin and leaves his body to be found in a deliberately humiliating fashion—wearing women's underwear and surrounded by gay porn—I was reminded of the scene early in Episode 1, when Cunanan claims to be straight and casually throws out the F-word ("I mean, what are we supposed to call them? Homosexuals sounds so scientific.") He doesn't just want Miglin dead—he wants him outed and humiliated, remembered as "a pansy." There's so much internalized homophobia in Cunanan, and it almost feels like Miglin seals his fate when he admits to having real feelings for him—moments before Cunanan calmly confesses that he's already "killed two people who were very close to me."
3) The tower conversation tells you everything you need to know about Cunanan's worldview.
Miglin is excited about the Sky Needle because he imagines families visiting together and children thrilled to ascend the tallest tower in the world. Cunanan, though, hones in on the fact that the hypothetical tower would loom over the Sears Tower, "so you can look down on the Sears Tower Observation Deck." To Cunanan, there's nothing more powerful than the idea of looking down on people.
The contrast between these two worldviews really comes into focus, though, when Miglin describes his fantasy of being able to visit his tower and "just roam among people, unannounced. They wouldn't know who I was!" But the notion of being anonymous is so galling to Cunanan that he flies into a sudden rage, affronted by Miglin's insistence that the tower is not about him. "Of course it's about you—it's the Lee Miglin Tower!" To Cunanan, there is no value in building anything for any reason other than putting your name on it.
4) Did a local radio station really scupper the Illinois police's investigation of Cunanan?
Miglin is an immensely powerful figure in the community, and as such the police are all over this case, managing to track Cunanan for some time using the car phone in the Lexus he stole from Miglin. But when a local radio station runs a news item giving that information away, Cunanan is able to ditch the car—claiming his fourth victim in the process—and evade justice for another two months.
Apparently, this happened in real life, too. Here's how it went down, according to Maureen Orth's Vanity Fair article "The Killer's Trail" (her book Vulgar Favors is the source material for this season of American Crime Story):
An activated car phone in [Miglin's] Lexus was used three times the following week in Pennsylvania. Philadelphia police confirmed a news report of the attempted phone calls, angering Chisago County sheriff Randall Schwegman, who told the Minneapolis Star-Tribune, “Everyone who was working on [the case] was outraged. Once he heard that, he’d have been a fool to use a phone after that.”
5) William Reese is the only victim not to have an episode to himself.
But he does get a death scene that's surprisingly affective for its brevity. Unlike Cunanan's other victims, there was no apparent personal connection between Cunanan and Reese, and investigators concluded he was killed solely for his truck. After giving Cunanan his keys, Reese calmly and politely begs for his life before being shot execution-style in the back of the head.
